About GENES

Join GENES

News

Press Releases

Contact

Resources

 

What’s wrong with the “It’s Theory not Fact” arguments?

 

 

Tennessee Science Education News

Recent events and news stories:

January 13, 2005:

Blount County School board unanimously approved a resolution relating to the teaching of biological origins and encouraging the teaching of Intelligent Design. Blount County School Board minutes for January 13, 2005. The resolution is reproduced below:

 

The following Resolution written by Dr. McNelly was approved by a motion from Mr. Booty Miller and seconded by Mr. Don Talbott. All were in favor. Motion carried.

 

As Members of the Blount County School Board

 

WE BELIEVE:

As a local public school board we have the authority and responsibility to approve curricula.

 

The teachers in our school system should enjoy academic freedom to present appropriate materials to their students pertaining to the subject matter being covered.

 

Students should not be deprived of current pertinent scientific information. The omission or denial of such information may unfairly deprive students of the opportunity to examine the full range of scientific theories about biological origins.

 

Presently our high school biology textbooks only present the theory of Darwinian evolution and omits teaching a variety of scientific theories about origins. By restricting content subject matter without academic freedom, biology education becomes indoctrination.

 

Further, we, as members of the Blount County School Board confirm:

1.   Teaching a variety of scientific theories about origins may be done with the clear secular intent of enhancing the effectiveness of science instruction.

2.   Design theory, in particular, constitutes an inference from biological data, and is not an inference or conclusion from religious authority.

3.   It is constitutionally lawful for teachers and school boards to expose students to scientific problems with current Darwinian theory as well as to other scientific alternatives with respect to theories about biological origins.

4.   It is unconstitutional under the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment to exclude these ideas from a public forum simply because of the content of these ideas.

5.   Biological origins is an open forum for free speech and as such cannot be censored based solely on the content of the speech.

6.   With respect to biological origins and scientific alternatives our local school board has the freedom to exercise discretion in the selection of curriculum materials.

7.   Therefore, we hereby encourage our biology teachers to teach the controversy with respect to biological origins. The theory of intelligent design may be taught as part of the current controversy. We also encourage the inclusion of intelligent origins in the State approved textbooks.

SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS

 

 

Chris Cantrell

 

 

John P. Davis, Jr.

 

 

Charles Finley

 

 

Dr. Don McNelly

 

 

William Miller

 

 

Donald L. Talbott

 

 

Mike Treadway

 

 

G.E.N.E.S
913 East Cumberland Drive
Louisville, TN 37777

Email: info@genesTN.org
Web: www.genesetn.org